Volume 16 • Issue 47 | April 16-22, 2004

The oyster is the pearl,group says?

Downtown Express photos by Elisabeth Robert

A few of The River Project’s oysters. The Tribeca group is studying the shellfish and hopes to bring them back to the Hudson River in a few years.

By Deborah Lynn Blumberg

In a warehouse on Pier 26, scientist Scott Wingerter plunges his hand into a large, circular tank filled with water from the Hudson River to retrieve a speckled oyster that contracts from his touch.

Wingerter and his fellow researchers at The River Project, a marine science field station on the N. Moore St. pier, have been growing oysters along the water in Tribeca for the past few years. Through the project’s oyster restoration program, researchers hope to reintroduce oysters to the Hudson River, where the shellfish once flourished.

“Up until 1900, the dominant ecosystem of the harbor was the oyster reef,” said Cathy Drew, the River Project’s executive director. “There were oyster stands on every corner and in bars, like hot dogs today. Everyone ate them.”

Several years ago, when River Project researchers started hearing reports of people finding oysters near the Statue of Liberty, they soon discovered oysters growing on their own pier and began to track the shellfish. In 2003, to study the creatures, they decided to harvest 1,000 of their own. The ultimate goal — to reestablish oyster reefs in the Hudson five years from now.

“In our lifetime, there’s no hope we could eat them, because the water contains heavy metal,” Drew said. “But we want them back to clean the water and to enrich the food web, which would attract other animals and birds to the area.”

She said theoretically, the group’s oysters are capable of making pearls, but she has yet to discover any gems in the ones that have been opened.

Jeremy Frenzel holds up a net which helps researchers determine the optimum conditions for the oysters.
Oysters act as natural water purifiers — scientists estimate that one oyster filters 25 to 50 gallons of water a day. Functioning oyster reefs, like coral reefs, also provide a habitat for fish and other marine organisms that live on the shells. When the Dutch arrived in what would soon become New York City in the early 1600s, they sailed over a river bottom paved with oysters. But over harvesting in the early 1900s and pollution in the 1960s and 1970s all but eliminated the shellfish from its waters.

“We project that if oysters were here in the numbers they used to be, they would clear the water in the harbor in a few days,” Drew said.

Over the past few years, the Hudson’s water quality has improved and oysters have reappeared, but only in small numbers. This summer, researchers will grow 2,000-3,000 more shellfish, and student interns will measure and monitor them to determine whether or not oysters could once again thrive in the river.

Inside the River Project’s main building, the round, fiberglass tank of oysters is just one element of the center’s 3,000-gallon aquarium system that houses fish such as grubby, shrimp, crabs and shad. Here, researchers observe the oysters to determine optimum growing conditions. Outside, another batch of oysters in a lantern-shaped tier net with five levels hangs into the Hudson from the pier’s wooden dock. Student interns like Davan Sooklal, 16, help staff to study the shellfish.

“We’re looking at where they will grow faster,” said Sooklal, a sophomore at New York’s Washington Irving High School. Along with 20 other student interns who design their own research projects, Sooklal works 12 hours a week at the pier through the Project’s marine biology internship, funded by the National Science Foundation. “I’m guessing they will grow faster in the river,” he said.

Jeremy Frenzel, the River Project’s assistant head of interns, said he never knew oysters lived in the bay until he joined the project a few months ago, after graduating from SUNY with a degree in fishery biology and aquatic science. Restoring oysters to the river is not a short-term project, he said, and will require years of research. “You can’t just take the oysters and throw them in the middle of the river,” he said. “If we can figure out how to get them reintroduced, it will take a significant amount of time to do it.”

Perhaps even five to 10 years, he said.

Drew hopes to create a small oyster reef at the pier in the next five years, and if the restoration project is ultimately successful, envisions a return of fish long gone from the river, such as the Black Drum and the Sheepshead fish—the namesake of Brooklyn’s Sheepshead Bay.

“If oysters were here again, they would support an ecosystem more diverse than what we have now,” Drew said. “Wild oysters are returning to the harbor. How long, if ever, it would take them to form coherent reefs is a big question.”

The Project’s pier is part of the Hudson River Park and the plan is to demolish and rebuild a stronger Pier 26 with a marine biology center such as The River Project if the Hudson River Park Trust secures enough money to build the rest of the park. Drew said if Pier 26 is closed for construction, she hopes she will be able to find a temporary home for her group at Pier 40 near Houston St.

The River Project was founded in 1986 and is open daily from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Free tours of the facility and its marine life are available upon request or by appointment. Schools can schedule class field trips from April through October.

The center is currently repairing several of the tanks and gathering fish from traps in the river. Researchers estimate that the tanks should be full by the end of next month. “It’s always up to the fish though, to a certain extent,” said Wingerter, the project’s head of interns. Employees are also planning several new self-educational stations on marine life and water conservation. Two such exhibits include one on horseshoe crabs and another on the cost of clean water.

On Sunday, April 25, from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., The River Project will host its first large-scale public event of the year, a shad bake. Center educators will discuss the history of shad in the bay as they cook the fish in the traditional method, on a wooden plank. Visitors can taste free samples and tour the aquarium.

Reader Services

Email our editor



Downtown Express is published by
Community Media LLC.

Downtown Express | 487 Greenwich St., Suite 6A | New York, NY 10013

Phone: 212.242.6162 | Fax: 212.229.2970
Email: news@downtownexpress.com

Written permission of the publisher must be obtainedbefore any of the contents of this newspaper, in whole or in part, can be reproduced or redistributed.