Volume 20, Number 29 | The Newspaper of Lower Manhattan | Nov. 30 - Dec. 6, 2007
"Support businesses and organizations that support Downtown Express"
Menin removes Landman after charged remarks
By Julie Shapiro
Community Board 1 Chairperson Julie Menin removed Rick Landman as chairperson of the Planning and Community Infrastructure Committee this week.
Menins decision came amid a furor over remarks Landman made in last weeks Downtown Express that were critical of Menin and the community board. Landman also said he planned to leave the board in the spring when his term expires.
After his comments, I think it was pretty obvious that something was going to happen, said Andrew Neale, co-chairperson of the Tribeca Committee. The comments he made were pretty despicable.
Landman criticized C.B. 1 for being too focused on childrens issues and referred to members as soccer moms and Menins flunkies in the Expresss UnderCover column.
I had about 20 e-mails and phone calls from both board members and members of the public outraged over these comments, Menin wrote in an e-mail to Downtown Express. We never can have various groups pitted against each other
Pejoratively attacking a certain segment of the board for wanting to build a future for the next generation is unproductive and only serves to divide and alienate people.
Menin said she removed Landman because he is planning to leave the board and she wanted someone who is focused long term. She appointed Jeff Galloway to replace him because Galloway is a lawyer with strong drafting and analytical skills who has experience with planning and ULURP (uniform land use review procedure), Menin wrote.
Im thrilled, Galloway said the day after his appointment. I think its important work.
Landman said he and Menin decided it would be best for him to step down as chairperson and he will finish out his term as a committee member.
I have had no problem staying on that committee and not being the chair, Landman wrote in an e-mail. My goal is to help the community I dont need to be the chair.
Landmans removal is a lesson in choosing words carefully, said Julie Nadel, chairperson of the Waterfront Committee.
Some words are deal breakers, Nadel said. If hed said too much attention is paid to families, OK. But soccer moms? Thats something else.
Landman confirmed the gist of his remarks in a Letter to The Editor in this weeks paper (page 16), pointing out that youth are the only group that has a committee to represent their interests. Downtown Express did incorrectly report that Landman concealed his sexual identity when he first applied to be a member of a community board 30 years ago.
Carole De Saram, chairperson of the Tribeca Committee who has had many disagreements with Landman over the years, said he has been disruptive at meetings, and that he has fallen out with previous C.B. 1 chairpersons as well.
He has a problem, but that should not be the community and the community boards problem, De Saram said. Its not fair to the community.
The Planning Committee, charged with drafting a master plan for Greenwich south, lost valuable time on this project under Landmans leadership, Menin said.
Landman replied that his committee drafted a resolution for Greenwich south last month, and then it went to the Financial District Committee for feedback. The resolution, which Landman said is quite timely, will return to the Planning Committee in December.
Menin added that several people left the Planning Committee because they were frustrated with Ricks chairing of the committee, particularly Landmans focus on the role of the committee, which has been a source of contention. Landman has criticized the power of C.B. 1s neighborhood committees, and wanted to centralize land use planning in one committee.
Landman now hopes people will fight to reform the structure of how planning is done at C.B. 1. Landman said he had strong, but not unanimous support on the committee.
Menin would consider altering the committee structure if the majority of board members supported the change. Several years ago, the majority wanted to keep the current structure, she said.
Some think that the Planning Committee itself is what needs to change.
A lot of people on the board questioned whether there was any need for the Planning Committee to begin with, Neale said. The geographical committees dealt with issues very well for long time, and will continue to do so.
For now, Galloway said its too soon into his term to start changing the role of the committee.
There is a history of geographic committees and that has worked by and large, he said. He expects to work with the geographic committees on planning issues that fall into their territory.
Galloway looks forward to working with Landman, saying, I hope to draw on his resources.
Downtown Express is published by Community Media LLC. 145 Sixth Avenue, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 229-1890 | Fax: (212) 229-2790 | Advertising: 646-452-2465 | © 2007 Community Media, LLC
Written permission of the publisher must be obtainedbefore any of the contents of this newspaper, in whole or in part, can be reproduced or redistributed.