City must balance needs of residents and nightlife better
When one thinks of New York City one of the things that springs to mind for many is nightlife. As everyone knows, the Big Apple is known as the city that never sleeps. Yet, the fact is, most people who actually live here do usually want to sleep, and therein lies the problem.
From the East Village and Lower East Side to Tribeca and Hudson Square, many residents are increasingly being driven to distraction by the noise and tumult from the citys burgeoning nightclub and bar scene. They cant relax and have peace of mind, much less get much-needed shut-eye.
The reasons why nightlife has become such a major quality-of-life issue are varied. In the case of the East Village and Lower East Side, there has obviously been an explosion of liquor-licensed establishments. Formerly relatively quiet neighborhoods have morphed into all-night party zones. The clubs are on narrow streets with residents living right above. Throw in the ubiquitous taxis that cater to the club crowd and its a recipe for disaster for residents.
Tribeca has been relatively quiet recently but there have been problems there in the past and any neighborhood is always one liquor license away from a problem.
The police quality-of-life blitz on Avenue B last Friday night was a long time coming. Residents on this thin avenue, particularly toward its Houston St. end, have been up in arms about the situation for some time now. The precincts new commander, Deputy Inspector Dennis De Quatro, deserves credit for marshaling police units for the operation, which should have put bar and club owners as well as the bargoers and the taxis, too on notice that the volume has to be kept down.
Making Avenue B one-way may offer some solutions. Like others, we think a study is first needed on whether the changes benefits will outweigh any negative impacts. And, we hope the police keep up their vigilance on the avenue, as De Quatro has promised.
But beyond such measures, the problems in the East Village, the Lower East Side and Hudson Square point to a larger problem that must be addressed, namely the need for a sensible plan by the city on nightlife. The New York Nightlife Association, for example, argues convincingly that its members purposely located in manufacturing zones to be away from residents, only to see the city grant residential variances near them. That led to problems in Tribeca, particularly before the zoning was changed to allow residents.
Community Board 3 is backing a rezoning of the East Village/Lower East Side. Yet to change the use-group 6 zoning that allows bars may take even longer. One would hope, however, that the city could expedite this process. Without a change, longtime residents will continue to be driven out of these new entertainment zones, while new residents and clubs will continue to clash in formerly all-nightlife areas.
Yes, nightlife is an important industry. But the city should start giving real thought to how to balance the needs of residents and nightlife so that the city that never sleeps can be that way for those who want to carouse, while for others, this can also be the city in which one can sleep.