Volume 18 • Issue 27 | November 18 - 24, 2005

C.B. 1 and Friends move toward ending unfriendly dispute

By Ronda Kaysen

Community Board 1 and the fundraising arm created in its name are on the way to becoming friends again, as the two groups agreed to create a fund for Downtown nonprofit groups.

C.B. 1 and Friends of Lower Manhattan, a nonprofit organization created in 2001 to raise money for the community board, have been at odds since Friends president, Madelyn Wils, left her post as C.B. 1 chairperson last spring. The organization changed its name from Friends of Community Board 1 last summer after C.B. 1 members voiced a desire to wield more control over the organization, which has nearly half a million dollars in its coffers.

In September, C.B. 1 sent Friends a proposal requesting, among other things, influence over the disbursement of the $500,000 that Friends raised through fundraising efforts and grants while it was closely aligned with C.B. 1.

On Nov. 4, Friends responded with a proposal of its own. The organization suggested creating a Friends-steered Community Fund comprised of five Friends appointees and five C.B. 1 appointees to disseminate $125,000 to Downtown nonprofit groups. C.B. 1 members responded favorably to the suggestion at a full board meeting on Tuesday night, requesting the group add an additional $5,000 to the program.

“The whole mood from both organizations is very positive,” C.B. 1 member Bill Love said in a telephone interview. Love is chairperson of Internal Workings of the Board, a task force vested with addressing the Friends dispute.

“We’re very close to an agreement,” C.B. 1 chairperson Julie Menin told board members at a Nov. 16 meeting.

The board also responded to Friends’ offer to contribute $120,000, which includes a $27,000 Red Cross Grant, to C.B. 1’s 2006 fiscal year budget. The board wants more control over how the money is distributed and requested the Red Cross grant in addition to the $120,000 contribution, raising the entire contribution to $147,000. With $125,00- set aside for a nonprofit grant program, the latest proposal accounts for half of the total money.

“This is a step in the right direction. It accounts for a substantial amount of the money,” said Love, adding that the board would ultimately like to reach an agreement regarding the remaining funds.

The two groups have a long history together. They were steered by the same leader — Wils — until last March and several board members continue to be members of Friends. The dispute has created tension between the intertwined organizations, tension that many hope to resolve.

“There are good, well-meaning people on both sides,” said Raymond O’Keefe, a C.B. 1 board member and a Friends member. O’Keefe also sits on the Internal Workings taskforce. “I can’t imagine any way that this wouldn’t work out to be a very pleasant and mutually beneficial relationship for Downtown.”

He declined to comment on the remaining funds.

Wils did not return calls for comment for this story.

Whether the groups will ultimately continue to work together after the remaining funds are spent remains to be seen. For now, both sides seem focused on the current proposal. “Both groups are kind of wary right now,” said Love. “It’s just a matter of working together and trying to build up some trust.”



Downtown Express is published by
Community Media LLC.
Downtown Express | 487 Greenwich St., Suite 6A | New York, NY 10013

Phone: 212.242.6162 | Fax: 212.229.2970
Email: news@downtownexpress.com

Written permission of the publisher
must be obtainedbefore any of the contents
of this newspaper, in whole or in part,
can be reproduced or redistributed.