State lets landlords benefit from illegal activity, advocates say

BY SAM SPOKONY | ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED NOV. 26, 2013  |Even though one of the city’s illegal hotel kingpins has now been shut down, housing advocates say that the resulting loss of rent stabilized apartments is still a major problem.

A year after the city filed a lawsuit against Smart Apartments (also known as Hotel Toshi) for violating a state law that bans tourist rentals of less than 30 days in residential apartments, Mayor Michael Bloomberg announced on Nov. 19 that a settlement had been reached.

Smart Apartments will pay a $1 million penalty to the city, and is now permanently prevented from doing business, according to statement released that day.

The city’s lawsuit cited approximately 50 buildings in Manhattan and Brooklyn that contained units used by Smart Apartments as illegal hotel rooms.

Seventeen of those buildings are located in the Downtown Manhattan area, at or below 14th St., according to a list released by the Mayor’s Office.

Assemblymember Linda Rosenthal is trying to restore rent protections on apartments in former illegal hotels.

Assemblymember Linda Rosenthal is trying to restore rent protections on apartments in former illegal hotels.

In at least one of those buildings, apartments that were formerly rent-stabilized — and which were, for years, used by Smart Apartments as illegal hotel units — are now being leased by the landlord for market rate rents.

“Our landlord was completely in cahoots with [Smart Apartments],” said a resident of 79 Clinton St., one of the buildings cited in the lawsuit, who asked to remain anonymous due to fear of reprisal from
the landlord. “Before [Smart Apartments] came in, the whole building was rent-stabilized. Then, they started using five of the apartments as illegal hotel rooms. And now that the illegal hotels are gone, we know that all those units now have tenants who are paying market rate.”

Gilman Management Corporation, the owner of 79 Clinton St., did not respond to a request for comment.

Housing advocates believe that landlords are now capitalizing off their association with Smart Apartments — which allowed them to use residential units for years without listing a legal tenant — by illegally de-regulating apartments that were once rent-stabilized.

Those advocates are also criticizing the state’s department of Homes and Community Renewal — which oversees rent regulation (as well as the similarly-initialed agency, D.H.C.R.) — for not launching an investigation into these allegedly illegal practices by the landlords.

“What we’re seeing is landlords using the vagueness of H.C.R. regulations to install illegal hotels in rent stabilized units,” said Tom Cayler, who leads the West Side Neighborhood Alliance’s Illegal Hotel Committee. “And if the landlords get caught, it’s actually a win-win situation for them, because even though they no longer have an illegal hotel unit, they now have a free market unit. And H.C.R. is doing nothing to rectify it. They have no interest, as far as I can see, in re-regulating units that were used for illegal hotels.”

Cayler added that he believes many units across the city have been unlawfully de-regulated as a result of illegal hotel use, and that the total impact of those practices will not be revealed until a thorough investigation is conducted.

A spokesperson for Homes and Community Renewal did not respond to a request for comment.

State Assemblymember Linda Rosenthal of the Upper West Side has also been pushing H.C.R. to investigate this issue, after learning that 89 rent-regulated apartments in a W. 73rd St. building may have been unlawfully de-regulated by way of illegal hotel use.

In a July 2012 letter to H.C.R., Rosenthal asked the state agency to examine the rent histories of each unit in the building, to determine which had been illegally de-regulated and to “aggressively enforce” rent regulations for those units.

Rosenthal followed that up with another letter this past January, but never got a response for H.C.R. in writing, she told Downtown Express.

Instead, she said an H.C.R. representative told her that investigating the allegedly illegal de-regulations was not a priority for the agency at that time.

“When all those units suddenly became de-regulated after the illegal hotel operation was gone, it was a perfect time for [H.C.R.] to step in and recapture them,” Rosenthal said last week. There are just too many New Yorkers in need of affordable housing for this to be overlooked…

“It’s such a simple case to make, but it just requires some effort.”



Spread the word:

3 Responses to State lets landlords benefit from illegal activity, advocates say

  1. Georgette Fleischer

    Thank you for this helpful and informative article. Little Italy has been decimated of affordable housing by this black market activity of illegal hotel rentals, in some cases with the collusion of landlords, and many of us wonder when our electeds will step forward to do something about it.

    Community Board 2 held a special meeting on November 4th about the fate of the Elizabeth Street Garden, one of the precious few open green spaces in our area that is being eyed for affordable senior housing by Councilmember Chin. If the illegal hotel rentals were ended we would have a treasure trove of residential units that could be re-purposed, to their original intended purpose: affordable housing. Ground-floor units could be offered on a first-rights basis to the elderly who may have trouble with stairs.

    I have not heard that adage in awhile that seems ready made for this situation: Housing for People, Not for Profit.

  2. The cure to the affordable housing problem is simple: build more housing.

    (re) Regulating the existing housing just causes landlords not to invest or to turn it into condos, hotels, or other non-residential uses. Like it or not, the 93 new apartments on the market are, in fact, helping to defuse the housing crisis.

  3. Nice one! The inherent connection in burning objects works well with the contrast between the actions of people and the movements of nature

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

three + 3 =