Real petition on counterfeits

Grab your fake purses and shoes, because City Councilmember Margaret Chin is hawking counterfeit legislation.

A petition from Chin’s office was sent to local representatives in support of a hearing for a legislation to curtail counterfeit commerce by making it a criminal offense to purchase fake trademark goods.

The legislation was introduced in April 2011, but a hearing did not result in the City Council. Local residents suggested starting an online petition to bring attention to the proposed bill, which would make it a Class A misdemeanor to purchase counterfeit goods, punishable by up to a $1,000 fine and/or up to a year in jail for repeat offenders, far more than one would save on bogus brands.

The petition says the ban would improve quality of life in neighborhoods like Tribeca, Soho, Chinatown. “Counterfeit vendors clog our sidewalks and streets; intimidate and harass local residents; destroy private property; and create a negative image of our neighborhood,” it reads.

But it seems there are ulterior motives as well: “The illegal counterfeit good trade costs New York City an estimated $1 billion in tax revenue each year. At a time when our city’s services are being slashed, it is irresponsible for our city to forgo such much-needed revenue.”

Some argue that the law would have a negative effect on business, especially on Canal St., where the lure of a knockoff handbag pulls NYC tourists from more scenic routes.

When the legislation was first proposed, the Chinese Chamber of Commerce’s David Louie objected to the method, saying that the first step should be enforcing the law against selling counterfeit goods that is already on the books.

“Some people have questioned whether the police would be able to implement it,” said Kelly Magee, Chin’s spokesperson, “But the local precincts are behind it.”

To view the petition, visit

Spread the word:

2 Responses to Real petition on counterfeits

  1. How about curtailing the lie of attaining a false sense of self worth by buying an expensive product when a cheaper, basic product will do the same form, fit, and function? Guys, a wallet is a wallet is a wallet. If you have to have a wallet with a designer stripe on it to impress family, friends, and strangers, then is the wallet counterfeit or are you? That's Gotta Hurt! Ok. Let me have it, but please don't rip my new genuine K-mart jeans. They cost me $7.00.

  2. / I and my friends haenpepd to be going through that the excellent tips and hintson your web blog and before long came up with a terrible feeling I never expressedrespect to the web blog owner for those techniques.My ladies were certainly glad to get them and have in effect surelybeen taking pleasure in those things. Thanks for actually being considerablyconsiderate and for pick out varieties of wonderful themesmillions of individuals are really desirous to discover about.My very own honest regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

− 3 = zero