Rajkumar has 37 grand to challenge Chin


Democratic District Leader Jenifer Rajkumar has raised over $37,000 in her as yet unannounced bid to unseat City Councilmember Margaret Chin later this year.

Rajkumar said she is only “exploring” a possible run, and said she would wait until a formal announcement before discussing the campaign’s issues. Her fundraising numbers were filed late in the day Tuesday so they were posted on the city Campaign Finance Board web site a day or so after the donors for Chin and many other city candidates were posted.

She said she has been raising money for only two weeks. “I am very pleased and moved and overwhelmed by the outpouring of support right in the beginning,” she said.

Rajkumar trails Chin, who has raised almost $ 97,000 from just over 800 donors, but it is not hard for challengers to raise enough money to run a credible campaign. Under the city’s generous public finance system, donations up to $175 are matched at a 6 to 1 ratio.

Rajkumar, 30, a Battery Park City resident and an attorney, defeated her Gateway Plaza neighbor, Linda Belfer, in last year’s district leader race.

One of Chin’s donors, John Fratta, a former district leader and a longtime ally of Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, said he expects to support Rajkumar someday for some office (“she’s very sharp”) — just not this year’s Council race.

“In politics one year you’re with me and the next you’re not,” he said. “I do look forward to supporting Jenifer for something.”

He said he admired her “youth and vibrancy” but Chin deserves reelection.

“Margaret has been a breath of fresh air,” he said. “She’s always fighting for what’s best for Lower Manhattan and Little Italy. “

Chin, 58, said with the expected matching funds, she is close to having the $168,000 limit she could spend in 2013 for a primary.

Only 19 of her donations were $1,000 or more and none were over $2,000. Her bigger donors include  Margery-Archie Gottesman of Edison Properties, which has a big development proposal in Hudson Square; Henry Buhl, a leader in the fight to create a Business Improvement District in Soho; and four members of the Gindi family, owners of the famed Century 21 department store across from the World Trade Center who gave a combined $5,000.

A look at Chin’s donor list shows many donations under $100 and many from people with Asian surnames — more than 100 are named Chen, for example. She also has support from community leaders throughout the district, raking in small donations from people like Catherine McVay Hughes, chairperson of Community Board 1 and Tobi Bergman, who runs a youth sports program on Pier 40.  Harold Reed, a C.B. 1 member who died unexpectedly last week in Hong Kong, donated $500.

By contrast, most of Rajkumar’s donations so far, nearly $30,000, have come from herself and eight others who have given at least $2,000.  Rajkumar gave herself $8,250, the maximum allowed to participate in the public finance system. Others are limited to $2,750 donations to her campaign.  She said four of her larger donors are family members, and the rest are friends and legal colleagues.

Also included in her donors are Jeanne Wilcke, president of Downtown Independent Democrats, which has been searching for an opponent for Chin, and two of Rajkumar’s neighbors Tom Goodkind, a D.I.D. member, and Michael Fortenbaugh, who also runs the marina near their Battery Park City homes.  PJ Kim, who lost to Chin four years ago, contributed as well, as did Adam Malitz of C.B. 1 and David Gruber, chairperson of C.B. 2.

Rajkumar, active with Young Democrats of New York, has also given a combined $210 to Julie Menin, the former C.B. 1 chairperson running for borough president, Yetta Kurland, running to succeed Council Speaker Christine Quinn in the neighboring district, Borough President Scott Stringer, now a candidate for City Comptroller, and Michael Treybich, a Young Democrat running for Council in Coney Island.

Chin and Rajkumar attended Tuesday night’s D.I.D. meeting in which Chin was one of the invited speakers. The club has always supported Chin’s opponents in her runs at the Council, although D.I.D. gave her glowing praise short of an endorsement in her successful run in 2009 to defeat Councilmember Alan Gerson.

As Chin spoke, Rajkumar sat close by, paying close attention while taking a few notes.

Other club members politely questioned Chin on issues like the proposed Soho BID and New York University’s development plans, which passed the Council last year. On the BID, she said she got organizers to exempt residential co-ops from the building owners’ tax and to do better outreach to neighbors.

On N.Y.U., she said the Council got the university to build a public school, scale back development by 25 percent, ensure permanent rent protections at 505 LaGuardia Pl., and expand open space in the area.

District Leader Paul Newell wondered if she got the best possible agreement. “If there was a better deal, Paul, we would have fought for it,” Chin replied.


Spread the word:

14 Responses to Rajkumar has 37 grand to challenge Chin

  1. I whole heartedly believe that the NYU 2031 plan was not reduced in size by 25%. Maybe 15% or 20% at the best. Personally, I hope Rajkumar does run for City Council so we can have a real debate on these issues and make sure that the voice of the community is heard. Heck, maybe I'll donate myself.

    • “{Chin} said the Council got the university to build a public school, scale back development by 25 percent”


      Borough President Stringer got a reduction in bulk of between 18-19%.

      Chin only got an additional 6% reduction. The total both politicians got NYU to reduce it was 25%, with Stringer doing the heavy lifting and receiving absolutely no credit from Chin for his efforts.

      It is disingenuous – if not an outright lie – for Chin to say she got 25%, when she only got a mere 6%.

      We won’t even discuss how Stringer got NYU to agree to build a grade school in return for the zoning change, but Chin, in her negotiations, has enabled NYU to renege on that promise.
      What can we expect when Chin let her young staffer do the complex negotiations instead of doing it herself.

      Nor will we discuss how Chin has ceded to NYU valuable parkland to stage their construction for the next two years.

      We could go on and on, but you get the picture.

  2. “Nor will we discuss how Chin has ceded to NYU valuable parkland to stage their construction for the next two years.”

    My bad. Make that TWENTY years.

  3. Concerned citizen

    Jenifer Rajkumar is great! We should definitely vote her in to City Council. A breath of fresh air!

  4. chin said referring to NY Project " you watch my back and I will watch your back" .
    The fact is while we watched your back you stabbed our.

  5. Councilmember Chin, at the DID "Interview the Candidates" meeting, also reiterated the testimony she gave at the SoHo BID Oversight Hearing in November:

    If the SoHo BID is to be enacted, then representation on the BID Board must be set at an even 50/ 50 split between commercial & residential stakeholders.

  6. He said he admired her “youth and vibrancy” so !!!!! Support her then

  7. Rajkumar sounds nice but needs way more grassroots experience. We've never heard of her on the Lower East Side, sounds like her base is more Battery Park City.

  8. Yay, Jenifer, let's do it ! Can't wait to get rid of that deceitful hack Chin!

  9. I think it's telling that the DID leadership is already cheerleading for the candidate who attracts the big $$ donations – or a Bloomberg-style self-funded campaign – and not the candidate who is receiving the broad support of small donations.

    If Chin won't be his puppet, he'll buy a different one.

  10. We do not need a social worker, we need a leader who is in people's corner. Jenifer has my vote if she decides to run.

  11. NewLeadershipPlease

    Jenifer's got my vote if she runs. Chin's record has been disappointing on so many issues as she has completely sold out to big money and real estate. Jenifer is the people's candidate in this race. Jenifer spent her entire career working in social justice causes. And she really, really cares about people. We need new leadership downtown that stands up for the people. I cannot say that Chin has stood up for us these past few years.

  12. Margaret Chin not only did not fight for a public school in the NYU 2031 Plan, but she actually gave it away by reducing from 18 years to 2 years the time period for the DOE to commit to funding school construction. This time period is impossible to achieve because the School Construction Authority (SCA) works on a 5 year budget cycle, hence giving away a much needed downtown public school.

    How inept to walk into a negotiation and come out with with LESS that was originally offered.

    If that was that the best deal that Chin could have gotten, then we need a new representative for City Council.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

nine − 9 =