Chinatown B.I.D. opponents vow to keep fighting

(Left to right) Alyce Lau, Mee Wong, Sou Lin Ng, Jan Lee and George Lou are vowing to continue fighting the Chinatown B.I.D. Downtown Express photo by Aline Reynolds

BY ALINE REYNOLDS  |  After a highly contentious debate among community members, the City Council unanimously voted in favor of the Chinatown Business Improvement District at its meeting on Wednesday, Sept. 21. Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s signed the legislation on Tuesday night.

More than three-quarters of the B.I.D.’s first-year budget, which totals $1.3 million, will be allocated to supplemental sanitation services, while the remaining funds will finance holiday lighting, maintenance of street lampposts and furniture and other area services. Assessment fees range from $1 for condominium owners to up to $5,000 for large property owners, the majority of whom will pay $700 annually. Approximately three-quarters of the district’s 2,300 property lots will owe $1,000 or less per year.

With respect to trash, the Council advised the future B.I.D. to increase garbage collection prior to 8 a.m. based on concerns raised by local business and property owners. “The B.I.D. will enhance and retain business in Chinatown by supplying very significant sanitation services within the B.I.D.’s boundary,” said Council Speaker Christine Quinn at a Sept. 21 press conference announcing the City Council vote.

The B.I.D. won’t be up and running until next year, since it typically takes between four and nine months for B.I.D.s to be established once they pass the Council, according to a spokesperson at the city’s Department of Small Business Services.

Councilmember Margaret Chin deemed the B.I.D.’s passage a victory for the neighborhood that was a long time in the waiting.

“This is a historic moment for us in the community and we will celebrate,” Chin said. “The bottom line is Chinatown residents and business owners deserve clean streets, more customers, and prosperity. Now, Chinatown will be ready to join the rest of Lower Manhattan in its rebirth. We will be able to enjoy a clean environment that’ll be great for everyone.”

Rather than garner additional support, however, the Council’s sweeping pro-B.I.D. vote only fanned the flames among its chief opponents such as neighborhood property owner Jan Lee. Lee, who helped amass 600 objections to the B.I.D. as part of an anti-B.I.D. campaign over the summer, said he was disappointed in the City Council for “completely ignoring any further investigation about the legitimacy of whether or not the community wants” the B.I.D.

That said, Lee is “optimistic” that the B.I.D. is a temporary entity rather than a permanent fixture in Chinatown. Lee and fellow property owners that objected to the B.I.D.’s passage are even considering taking legal action against the entity once it is formed.

“We’re going to continue with protesting, [Freedom of Information Law] requests, and inquires,” said Lee. “We will use every resource available to us until the B.I.D. is fully dismantled.”

According to the city’s Department of Small Business Services, B.I.D.s can be dissolved if at least 51 percent of the district’s property owners, or alternatively the property owners of 51 percent of the district’s total assessed value, submit written petitions to City Council.

“The B.I.D. law makes provisions for B.I.D.s that have been installed and are unpopular,” said Lee. “We will make every effort to prove legally that this is not only unpopular, but that it was installed completely under dubious conditions.”

Lee and other neighborhood property owners are now fearful of losing their ground-floor commercial tenants, some of whom have said they would have to close down shop if they incur an additional expense.

Sam Kwok, owner and manager of Shanghai Asian Manor at 21 Mott St., would have to fork over hundreds of dollars more to Lee per year once the B.I.D. is in place. As a result, Kwok said he might have to shut down his restaurant entirely. All 30 restaurant employees would be out of work since he wouldn’t be able to afford opening his business at another location.

“I’m very upset,” said Kwok. “We can maintain streets [on our own]. We don’t need an organization to do this.”

“I’m worried I might not have my job,” said Kelly Chang, assistant manager of the Manor. “It’s not easy to find a job nowadays, so if he closes, it’s really bad. Hopefully a miracle happens.”

An added fee would be an insult to injury for Robert Purnick, owner of a Mott Street retail store named Whole World Fashion Boutique, who said he might have to shutter his business because revenues are declining every month. Purnick and other local business owners are responsible as is to pay for private carter companies to collect their trash.

“It just seems like a total waste,” Purnick said of the B.I.D. “We have to clean in front of our stores and pay for sanitation anyhow.”

“I find it pretty unfair. We pay the tax [already], and the city’s supposed to do the cleaning,” echoed Mee Wong, who owns property at 88-90 Walker St.. “We don’t need a duplicate expense to clean the street.”

Chin, however, contends that B.I.D.s are implemented precisely to help businesses flourish, to not hinder their success. The assessment fees, she explained, will be offset by the profits businesses will rake in from the added clientele the B.I.D. will encourage by way of signage, advertising and other forms of publicity. “When we attract more business into the community and the community becomes more prosperous, I think a lot of these business owners will also be able to prosper and pay the fees,” said Chin.

Other neighborhood property and business owners believe the B.I.D. will supply much-needed supplemental services to the community. Longtime neighborhood property owner Wellman Wu, who owns buildings on Mott and Canal Streets, said he isn’t worried about the assessment fees.

“I just consider that as part of our business espense,” Wu. “People do some service, you have to pay for it. If it’s a dirty area, then we will lose our customers.”

Peter Lau, who owns and runs two pharmacies in Chinatown, believes the area’s improved streetscape will improve Chinatown’s reputation and therefore generate higher revenues.

“As local residents and business owners, we feel we are uplifted in a way by cleaner streets,” said Lau. “And, if you have better lighting, people will want to come and shop more, and the neighborhood will become more desirable.”

Bethany Li, a staff attorney at the Asian-American Legal Defense and Education Fund, argued that the gentrification caused by the B.I.D. would eventually lead to the displacement of local residents and small businesses.

“The developers are quoted as saying they’re welcoming the approval of the B.I.D. because they see it as a nice link and next step towards [re]zoning Canal Street to allow for more luxury high-end development,” said Li.

Chin, however, insists that the B.I.D. will improve the quality of life in Chinatown without ousting residents or businesses.

“I do not buy the argument that a B.I.D. will cause gentrification or a rapid increase in property values. That’s not the way it works,” said Chin. “These criticisms are leveled by the same people who oppose any and all efforts to make our community better.”

Spread the word:

6 Responses to Chinatown B.I.D. opponents vow to keep fighting

  1. Chinatown Property O

    The Chinatown BID has the MOST Verified Objections filed against it with the City Clerk – more Verified Objections than ANY other BID in NYC BID history! At the recent NYC Council hearings, CM Chin clearly has NOT acknowledged this glaring fact: Chinatown does NOT want the BID to go forward! It is a huge mistake for any councilmember to ignore his/her constituents, and in this case it's an insult to the Chinatown property owners who very quickly filed this RECORD HIGH NUMBER OF VERIFIED OBJECTIONS against this regressive Chinatown BID that threatens to financially burden those who can least afford it the most!! To the City Council and Mayor Bloomberg: The Chinatown BID has the MOST Verified Objections filed against it with the City Clerk – more Verified Objections than ANY other BID in NYC BID history!

  2. Chinatown is changing again; it has done this at least twice before in the last 30 years or so.u00a0 The result is a less vibrant Chinatown u2014 shifting residential demographics, altered commercial foundations, changing capital investment and formation and generally lots less fun.u00a0 Will the BID help?u00a0 Not if it is just a street-cleaning, pole-decorating agency.u00a0 Neither will it stop gentrification (Chin is right: the BID won't cause it; it's already happening and will continue).u00a0 Two really smart moves: ABC Restaurant developed a "prix fixe" dinner menu and advertised it to Downtown Express readers (lots of people outside Chinatown); it's a reasonable deal for a nice dinner presented in what is a different way for Chinatown Cantonese restaurants (and the wine was drinkable!).u00a0 Grand Harmony serves great food, and a couple nights a week, clears the dance-floor of tables and takes on a supper-club feeling (which the room's decor supports nicely).u00a0 A BID that develops a support structure for real innovations of this kind will keep Chinatown viable; a BID that just cleans the streets won't.u00a0 As for the whining weanies: Losers, all of 'em.

  3. u00a0The BID can be a HUGE stepping stone into changing Chinatown for the better. u00a0I dont even walk down certain streets anymore because of how dirty and smelly it is (Mott between Hester and Grand). u00a0Why would you want to fight progress? u00a0You pay a little for a bigger reward. u00a0Anybody smart business person should know this. u00a0People like jan lee want to be the voice of Chinatown, but you don't become a respected voice of Chinatown by bashing people who have been nothing but beneficial to the Chinatown Community and have documented community service under their belt. u00a0 I stronglyu00a0believeu00a0the board members know what their doing. u00a0So what if their getting paid for it? u00a0Their providing a beneficial service to help everyone else, last time i checked that wasn't free. u00a0 I've been doing community service for years and let me tell you its not easy. u00a0It takes a lot of time and effort into getting sponsors to sponsor whatever you're trying to do. u00a0I'd like to do more however i don't have a budget to do it. u00a0If i was paid to do community service i'd do it all day! u00a0 u00a0 Despite having the largest number of opposition for a BID, the Chinatown BID had to get the approval of 3 Community Boards, and was votedu00a0UNANIMOUSLY through the city Council. u00a0I think that should be a betteru00a0indication of what the "community wants" instead of the small minority of naysayers. u00a0If you can't beat em join em right? u00a0The Chinatown BID is not opposed to listening to what the community wants. u00a0If you want to help Chinatown, work WITH the BID, they'll hear you out. u00a0After all its your money that's keeping the BID going. u00a0The BID is not about greed and in a few years we'll all see that. u00a0the BID is about progression and working with the Chinatown Community for a better Chinatown Community. u00a0nnPlease forgive my grammar, i'm not the most articulate person in the world. u00a0I'm just a Chinatown resident and community service advocate who would love to see my neighborhood progress along with the rest of the city. u00a0 We can't be stuck in old times, we need to come together as one and stop with this crabs in a bucket mentality. u00a0 u00a0u00a0u00a0

  4. Fabulous, what a weblog it is! This website provides useful data to us, keep it

  5. You need to take part in a contest for one of the greatest blogs online.
    I’m going to recommend this website!

  6. Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, like
    you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with a few pics to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is excellent blog.
    A fantastic read. I’ll certainly be back.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

− 5 = zero